DATING shows aren’t built to find “real love” — they’re built for chaos, conflict and memorable moments, say reality TV insiders.

One series that comes in for particular scrutiny is Too Hot To Handle. Senior showbiz reporter Jake Penkethman argued it barely even qualifies as a dating show, saying its rules and structure “go against everything you would expect” from the genre and instead push it towards a reality competition. His take: contestants are essentially “competing to retain an amount of money”, making it feel like “reality for reality’s sake”.

Too Hot To Handle famously asks contestants to abstain from physical intimacy and focus on building a genuine connection to win a big prize pot — while the format also drops temptation in their path.

Deputy TV Editor Felicity Cross called the show’s set-up “hypocrisy”, arguing it highlights a wider issue with dating formats: they’re supposed to be about finding love, but production choices are “constantly trying to sabotage that”.

The numbers don’t exactly scream fairy tale either. Data suggests Too Hot To Handle has a five per cent success rate for couples finding love, while Ex On The Beach sits at four per cent. Love Island does better on ten per cent — but Penkethman thinks not coupling up can actually be the smarter career move.

He pointed to the way memorable single contestants can be rewarded with more TV opportunities, from All Stars invitations to crossing over onto other shows. He also named Scott Van Der Sluis, Casey O’Gorman and Curtis Pritchard as examples of Love Island faces who’ve “made a career out of being single” — and, in his words, it’s “clearly worked really, really well for them.”

POP QUEST COMMENTS

Do you watch dating shows for actual romance — or for the chaos and career-making characters?

3 comments · real people, real opinions

@PQ_SadiePop Quest host27 minutes ago
The ‘hypocrisy’ point is bang on. Producers want love on the poster, but chaos in the edit. If the format keeps nudging people to mess it up, what exactly are we pretending the show’s about?
@PQ_ArjunPop Quest host53 minutes ago
Those success-rate numbers are bleak: 5% and 4% is basically ‘blink and you’ll miss the relationship’. Love Island hitting 10% is still low, but it’s interesting that being single can apparently be the better long-term strategy.
@PQ_MiaPop Quest host1 hour ago
Too Hot To Handle always felt like a prank on the idea of romance. A prize pot + temptation is basically a party game with microphones. No shade — it’s entertaining — but calling it ‘dating’ is doing a lot of heavy lifting.
MAKE THIS YOUR FEED

Stay for the conversation, not just one story.

Follow people and topics you care about, save stories, and come back to a feed that gets better the more you use it.

Create your free profile