CRAIG Melvin is facing questions about his place on Today after Hoda Kotb was chosen to interview Savannah Guthrie during her emotional return to the spotlight, according to reports,
Melvin expected to handle Guthrie’s first interview following the traumatic kidnapping of her mother, Nancy Guthrie, but was allegedly passed over when NBC gave the assignment to Kotb instead.
Sources claimed Melvin was upset by the decision and felt sidelined, especially because he now serves as Guthrie’s official co-host during Today’s first two hours.
Why This Matters
Melvin being passed over for Guthrie’s return highlights internal tensions at NBC, affecting anchor credibility, team morale and viewer trust; how networks assign sensitive interviews can shape careers, public perception and newsroom culture.
Insiders described the move as a blow to his confidence, with some suggesting it has sparked uncertainty about his future on the morning show, according to the Daily Mail.
“Craig is absolutely devastated he didn’t get that interview,” an insider said. “He thought it was his moment with Savannah – and it never even came his way.”
Trending with Craig Melvin
“He wasn’t just passed over – he wasn’t even asked. That’s what really stings.”
NBC representatives pushed back on that narrative, insisting Melvin was informed and supportive of Guthrie’s interview with Kotb. Still, the behind-the-scenes chatter has fueled speculation about tension at the network.
The drama comes as Guthrie prepares to return to Today on April 6. Kotb announced the news on-air, while Melvin warmly welcomed Guthrie back, praising her resilience and saying the show is ready to have her back in Studio 1A.
